Certified payroll software, compared honestly
These five tools are not interchangeable. One is a payroll system with a WH-347 report, one is an enterprise payroll platform, one is a dedicated compliance suite, one is a low-cost project tool, and one is a browser-based form filler with the rules attached. The right choice depends on where your payroll already lives.
The short answer
If your payroll already runs in QuickBooks or ADP, start there — the marginal cost of the certified payroll report is usually lower than adding a second system. If you need many state forms, audit support and managed reporting, a dedicated platform such as Points North is built for that. If you are a small subcontractor who needs the form, the deadline and the rejection checks without a sales call, a lighter tool is enough.
No tool on this page determines your wage determination, chooses the correct classification, signs the Statement of Compliance or files with the agency on your behalf. Those are still your responsibilities.
Side by side
| Tool | Best fit | Federal WH-347 | State forms | Data model | Public pricing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| QuickBooks Online Payroll | Contractors already running payroll in QuickBooks | Yes — a certified payroll report (WH-347) is available in QuickBooks Workforce | Limited; check the state before relying on it | Cloud payroll | Bundled into payroll plans; the plan price is published, the certified payroll add-on varies |
| ADP | Larger contractors, multi-state payroll, existing ADP relationship | Yes — certified payroll reporting is part of its construction offering | Broad through construction modules; confirm the states you file in | Cloud payroll | Quote-based |
| Points North | Dedicated prevailing-wage compliance, many jurisdictions, audit preparation | Yes | 100+ federal and state forms advertised; integrates with ADP and QuickBooks | Cloud compliance platform | Quote-based |
| WeeklyCertified | Small federal-only subcontractor who wants a low entry price | Yes — January 2025 WH-347 | State format add-ons as released | Browser for the free generator; paid archive stored | Public: 3 free forms/month; $49 project pass (60 days); $29 Solo / $59 Crew per month |
| WageDecoder | Small subcontractor who wants the form plus the rule and the rejection checks explained | Yes — January 2025 WH-347, no watermark | Nine verified state rule pages; the tool produces the federal form and explains state forms rather than generating every state PDF | Browser only; saved crews and projects stay in local storage | Public: unlimited free single forms; $99 project pass (12 months); $29/month; $149/month Firm |
WeeklyCertified figures were taken from its public pricing page on 2026-11-18. QuickBooks and ADP prices vary by plan, headcount and modules; Points North is quote-based. Confirm every price on the provider's site before buying.
Choose by workflow, not by logo
- Where does the payroll already run? If it runs in QuickBooks or ADP, producing the certified payroll there avoids a second data entry and a second reconciliation.
- How many states do you file in? One federal-only job is a different problem from a multi-state contractor with a compliance officer. The first can use a light tool; the second usually needs a platform with form libraries and audit trails.
- Do you need a filing service or a form? Producing the form and filing it are different services. Some platforms manage submissions; most tools only produce the PDF.
- Where must the data live? Cloud systems give an archive and multi-user access. Browser-only tools keep payroll data on the device. Neither is automatically better; they are different trade-offs.
- What does it cost all-in? A “free” form tool plus your time each week is not free. A quote-based platform plus implementation is not cheap. Price the workflow, not the sticker.
Where each one fits
QuickBooks Online Payroll is the least disruptive choice if your payroll is already there. Intuit documents a certified payroll report for WH-347, which means the hours and rates you already enter can be turned into the federal form. The limit is state-specific coverage: a state form or portal may still be a separate step.
ADP is built for payroll at scale and has a construction offering that includes certified payroll reporting and project setup. It is a sensible fit when ADP already runs your payroll and you need multi-state, multi-entity reporting. It is usually more platform than a two-person subcontractor needs.
Points North is a dedicated compliance platform rather than a payroll system. It advertises a large federal and state form library and integrations with payroll systems, which fits contractors whose main problem is breadth of jurisdictions and audit preparation, not entering hours.
WeeklyCertified is aimed at the same small-subcontractor market as WageDecoder. Its free tier is metered at three forms a month and its project pass runs 60 days. That is a good fit for a short federal job; a longer job may prefer a pass that does not expire mid-project.
WageDecoder is deliberately narrower. It produces the federal WH-347 in the browser and publishes verified rule pages for nine states, with the form, clock and threshold explained. It does not generate every state's PDF and does not file. The trade-off is transparency and price, not breadth.
What no tool does
- Pick the wage determination. It comes from the contract. A tool can store the number; it cannot decide which determination is legally incorporated.
- Classify the worker. The classification must match the work and appear in the determination. Software can warn; it cannot make the judgment for you.
- Sign the Statement of Compliance. The signature belongs to an authorised person at the contractor. A generated signature is not a certification.
- File with the agency. Unless the provider explicitly sells managed filing, the submission is yours.
QuickBooks certified payroll
QuickBooks Online Payroll can produce a federal certified payroll report for WH-347 in QuickBooks Workforce. It is the least disruptive option if your hours and rates already live in QuickBooks. Its coverage of state forms and state portals is the part to check before you rely on it for a Pennsylvania or California job.
ADP certified payroll
ADP's construction offering includes certified payroll reporting and project setup, which fits contractors already running ADP payroll across multiple entities or states. It is usually more platform than a two-person subcontractor needs, and pricing is quote-based.
Certified payroll reporting software for small contractors
For a small subcontractor, the deciding question is whether you need a payroll system or just the form. If payroll already runs elsewhere, a browser-based form tool with the rule checks is enough. If you file in several states and need an audit trail, a dedicated compliance platform is the better fit.
Questions
Which certified payroll software is best for a small subcontractor?
It depends on where the payroll already lives. If it is in QuickBooks Online Payroll, its WH-347 report is the least disruptive option. If you only need the form and the rule explanation, a lighter browser tool is enough. If you file in many states with audit support, a dedicated platform is the better fit.
Do these tools file the payroll for me?
Generally no. They produce the form or data file. Filing, signing and determining the correct wage determination remain the contractor's responsibility unless the provider explicitly sells a managed filing service.
Why do some vendors not publish prices?
Payroll and compliance platforms often price by employee count, state count, modules or contract value. Ask for the all-in cost for your headcount and the states you file in, including implementation.
Can I use two tools at once?
Yes. The deliverable is a PDF or a portal submission, not a proprietary lock-in. Some contractors run payroll in one system and produce the certified payroll in another.
Does QuickBooks have certified payroll?
QuickBooks Online Payroll can produce a federal certified payroll report for WH-347 in QuickBooks Workforce. Check its state form and portal coverage separately before relying on it for a state-covered job.
Does ADP do certified payroll?
Yes. ADP's construction offering includes certified payroll reporting and project setup. Pricing is quote-based, so ask for the all-in cost for your headcount and states.
Try the free form before comparing plans
Fill this week's payroll, see the rejection checks, and download the official PDF. No account, no sales call, nothing uploaded.